The Daily Oklahoman has done it again.
On December 2, 2018, the Daily Oklahoman op-ed board published
an editorial encouraging skepticism about the latest climate report.
Let’s take a look at it, word for word.
A
new federal report on climate change predicts dire consequences if action isn't
taken. Human sacrifice. Dogs and cats living together. Mass hysteria.
Cute. 350 million people live within 5 meters of sea level.
I’m sure none of them would seek American shores if they were displaced.
Sorry,
that's Bill Murray in “Ghostbusters.”
Way to reach out to the millennials.
But
Murray's classic oration is only an exaggerated form of the predictions
contained in the report, which include early death, food shortages and pestilence.
Thus, environmentalists are dismayed that President Trump and much of the
public have responded with a shrug.
They
shouldn't be surprised, because there is little appetite for embracing
meaningful climate change policies…
This isn’t a straight-out lie, but the polling data doesn’t
confirm this declaration. 61% of Americans are worried about global warming. (The
number is lower in Oklahoma, where the economy depends on fossil fuels, and we
are 1,100 feet above sea level.)
A reasonable counter-argument could be made that this data
doesn’t match up with people’s voting behaviors. For example, 69% of Washingtonians
said they would support a carbon tax, but such a proposal recently got trounced
in the polls. “Little appetite for embracing meaningful climate change policies”
is certainly a gray area.
…and there's a long history of such reports
crying wolf.
OK, this is patently untrue. Climate models have been
confirmed over and over and over again.
Those 250 ZJ are equivalent to 4,000,000,000 Hiroshima
bombs.
If anything, the models have been too optimistic. The recent
collapse of arctic sea ice caught everyone off guard.
But let’s dismiss all computer models. Let’s dismiss all
extrapolations, all predictions. Let’s look at what has already happened:
The 2009 climate report gives 10 real-world, verifiable
signs that bad things are happening. Right now.
From skepticalscience.com ---
The 10 indicators are:
- Land surface air temperature as measured by weather stations. You know all those skeptic arguments about how the temperature record is biased by the urban heat island effect, badly-sited weather stations, dropped stations, and so on? This is the only indicator which suffers from all those problems. So if you’re arguing with somebody who tries to frame the discussion as being about land surface air temperature, just remind them about the other nine indicators.
- Sea surface temperature. As with land temperatures, the longest record goes back to 1850 and the last decade is warmest.
- Air temperature over the oceans.
- Lower troposphere temperature as measured by satellites for around 50 years. By any of these measures, the 2000s was the warmest decade and each of the last three decades has been much warmer than the previous one.
- Ocean heat content, for which records go back over half a century. More than 90% of the extra heat from global warming is going into the oceans – contributing to a rise in…
- Sea level. Tide gauge records go back to 1870, and sea level has risen at an accelerating rate.
- Specific humidity, which has risen in tandem with temperatures.
- Glaciers. 2009 was the 19th consecutive year in which there was a net loss of ice from glaciers worldwide.
- Northern Hemisphere snow cover, which has also decreased in recent decades.
- Perhaps the most dramatic change of all has been in Arctic sea ice. Satellite measurements are available back to 1979 and reliable shipping records back to 1953. September sea ice extent has shrunk by 35% since 1979.
So let’s skip the crying wolf language, ok?
To
reduce global warming, activists…
You misspelled scientists
…say
nations must reduce greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuels. But policies
forcing people to do so are wildly unpopular, as can be seen in France, where
rioting occurred after a fuel tax increase was passed to reduce fossil-fuel
consumption.
The fuel riots in France are intriguing. Fuel costs have
always been high in France, and the vast majority of that cost is borne by the
rural French, who see Parisians as being out of touch, and who naturally drive
far more miles than city-dwellers.
It
appears that may have been the proverbial straw that broke the camel's back,
since the latest tax hike left consumers paying the U.S. equivalent of $7 a
gallon for fuel.
Not unprecedented for France.
An
estimated 283,000 people joined public demonstrations, which turned violent at
times. French President Emmanuel Macron's popularity rating has fallen into the
20 percent range.
True. Macron is at 26%, and the diesel situation has not
helped. I’m curious that this op-ed is approaching “we fear the mob” language.
Writing
for Commentary, Abe Greenwald notes that it “turns out that people — not just
Americans — care deeply about melting ice caps and rising sea levels only under
specific circumstances. Namely, when they can be blamed on the greed and
stupidity of their political enemies. They find that they suddenly care a lot
less when addressing climate change means shelling out a few extra euro cents.
So the French came out in droves, lit bonfires, tore up some buildings, blocked
streets, and chanted slogans.”
I see where he’s going with this. Like the Washington carbon
tax referendum I mentioned earlier, it’s hard to get the public to pay directly
for policy changes. Thank goodness we can just put other expensive programs on
the federal credit card and move on.
The
German government's aggressive efforts to transition to green power have not
prompted rioting (yet), but they have raised living costs substantially,
burdening the poor.
Guess what? Cost of living in Germany is 5% lower than the
United States. Rent is 26% lower than the United States. And look at the nightmare
that is German inflation:
And,
even though renewables make up about 40 percent of Germany's electricity supply,
that nation's greenhouse gas emissions continue to rise.
This data point is some thin soup. I assume they
are citing a recent Forbes report that German GHG has gone up. But emissions have
dropped (pretty steadily) by 25% since 1990.
When
people are asked to choose between expensive electricity and expensive fuel and
continued global warming, or affordable and plentiful fuel supplies along with the
same global warming, most are going to favor the latter.
This is quickly becoming a false dichotomy. The cost of
solar power has fallen by 99% since 1980. Life-cycle cost for solar is now at
$150 per MW-hr, compared to $100 for coal and $65 for natural gas, and that’s even
without the benefits of mass-production. We’re quickly getting to the point where
solar is going to be just as cost-effective as natural gas. That $150 vs $65 is
real money – it comes to about $1,000 a person per year, so we need to bring
that cost down. Which is kind of the point of the study.
People
also have reason to doubt severe environmental predictions. In a recent column,
economist Stephen Moore notes, “The same analysts who tell us how much climate
change will cost the economy in terms of lost gross domestic product cannot tell
us with much accuracy what output will be two years from now.”
Save this argument for the tourists, Stephen. We are really
really good at predicting long term trends. Nobody is good at predicting short
term trends. Let’s say you are riding an elevator to the top of a skyscraper,
and while you’re riding, you throw a superball against the floor. It will be
impossible to tell where the ball will be at any given time, but you can be
fairly sure that in a few minutes the ball will be at the top of the building.
In
past decades, Moore notes, environmental experts have wrongly predicted
overpopulation would make Britain's long-term survival a 50-50 proposition and
the world would be more polluted and less stable after 2000.
Moore is citing Paul Ehrlich’s study on overpopulation in 1968.
Congratulations, it only took you 50 years to find a scientist to criticize.
Ehrlich’s The Population Bomb
predicted dire environmental consequences if population growth continued. Overpopulation
is still a major problem; things are not as dire as Ehrlich predicted, for two
main reasons:
·
Birth rates are way, way down, worldwide. Not
just in Mao’s dystopia, but in nearly every country in the world. Birth rates
go down when quality of life goes up. Sure, things dropped in totalitarian China
and Saudi Arabia, but they dropped just as much in freedom-loving South Korea.
·
Agricultural yields (calories per acre) are way,
way up.
(So why are people still starving? Ask your congressman.)
Even so, Ehrlich’s claim of increased pollution rings true.
We’ve cut lots of pollution sources (CFCs, DDT, NOx, SOx, lead based paint, etc
etc etc.). But CO2 levels are reaching catastrophic levels.
Ongoing
technological progress, innovation and adaptation have continually proved naysayers
wrong.
Um, I think we’re actually saying that these three things
have to happen.
That's
why there is little reason to believe the apocalypse is nigh. And there's no
reason to embrace government policies that would reduce quality of life far
more than what might occur because of climate change.
Adding a new argument in the last sentence? Sure, why not. It’s
pretty specious to argue that quality of life will be reduced by green energy. Americans
consume about 1350 watts per capita.
Zooming in on Europe:
That’s right. We’re consuming about twice as much electricity
per capita than those backwater countries such as (checks notes) France and Germany.
And if you think that’s because of air conditioning, think
again. Residential air conditioning accounts for 74 of our 1350 watts. If we
cut our consumption from 1350 watts to 1000, we could be done with coal.
I’m not even a big conservation proponent. I maintain we
need much, much more generation, especially in developing nations. I’m just
saying that cutting our consumption wouldn’t be “a reduction in quality of life”.
Or are you claiming that Americans have gone soft?
The weird thing about all this is, I’m not in the doomsday
camp. I can’t function with that weight on my shoulders. What I am saying is we
need, quickly and desperately:
Significantly
higher green electricity generation
Significant
advancements in electricity storage
Quick
transition to electric vehicles
(Then
and only then) large-scale carbon sequestration.
And what happens if we do nothing?
Here’s the short list (again, from skepticalscience.com)
·
Decreasing human water
supplies, increased fire frequency, ecosystem change and expanded deserts (Solomon 2009)
·
Increase of Western
United States wildfire activity, associated with higher temperatures and
earlier spring snowmelt (Westerling 2006)
·
Encroachment of shrubs
into grasslands, rendering rangeland unsuitable for domestic livestock grazing
(Morgan 2007)
·
Decreased water supply
in the Colorado River Basin (McCabe 2007)
·
Decreasing water
supply to the Murray-Darling Basin (Cai 2008)
- Increased deaths to heatwaves - 5.74% increase to heatwaves compared to 1.59% to cold snaps (Medina-Ramon 2007)
- Increased heat stress in humans and other mammals (Sherwood 2010)
- Spread in mosquite-borne diseases such as Malaria and Dengue Fever (Epstein 1998)
- Increase in occurrence of allergic symptoms due to rise in allergenic pollen (Rogers 2006)
·
Loss of 2/3 of the
world's polar bear population within 50 years (Amstrup 2007)
·
Less compacted ice,
hazardous floes and more mobile icebergs posing increased risk to shipping (IICWG 2009)
·
Drying of arctic ponds
with subsequent damage to ecosystem (Smol 2007)
Warming causes methane
to escape from Arctic regions, contributing additional greenhouse warming. The
following have been observed:
·
Melting of Arctic
lakes leading methane bubbling (Walter 2007)
·
Leakage of methane
from the East Siberian Shelf seabed sediments (Shakhova 2008)
·
Escape of methane gas
from the seabed along the West Spitsbergen continental margin (Westbrook 2009)
- Rainforests releasing CO2 as regions become drier (Saleska 2009)
- Extinction of the European land leech (Kutschera 2007)
- Decrease in Adélie penguin numbers (Ducklow 2006)
- Disruption to New Zealand aquatic species such as salmonids, stream invertebrates, fishes (Ryan 2007)
- Oxygen poor ocean zones are growing (Stramma 2008, Shaffer 2009)
- Increased mortality rates of healthy trees in Western U.S. forest (Pennisi 2009)
- More severe and extensive vegetation die-off due to warmer droughts (Breshears 2009)
- Increased pine tree mortality due to outbreaks of pine beetles (Kurz 2008, Bentz 2010)
- Increased risk of coral extinction from bleaching and disease driven by warming waters (Veron 2009, Carpenter 2008)
- Decline in lizard populations (Sinervo 2010)
- Decline in global phytoplankton (Boyce 2010)
- Decline in global net primary production - the amount of carbon absorbed by plants (Zhao 2010)
- Substantial negative impacts to marine ecosystems (Orr 2005, Fabry 2008, Kroeker 2010)
- Inhibiting plankton development, disruption of carbon cycle (Turley 2005)
- Increased mortalities of sea urchins (Miles 2007)
- Threat to fish populations (Munday 2010)
- Severe consequences for at least 60 million people dependent on ice melt for water supply (Barnett 2005, Immerzeel 2010)
- Contribution to rising sea levels (Pfeffer 2008, Vermeer 2009)
- Economic damage to poorer, low latitude countries (Mendelsohn 2006)
- Billions of dollars of damage to public infrastructure (Larsen 2007)
- Reduced water supply in New Mexico (Hurd 2008)
- Increased risk of conflict (Zhang 2007) including increased risk of civil war in Africa (Burke 2009)
- Drop in primary productivity due to unprecedented warming at Lake Tanganyika (Tierney 2010)
- Hundreds of millions displaced within this century (Dasgupta 2009)
But hey, Ghostbusters, right?













Comments
Post a Comment